C. Robeller, V. Helm, A. Thoma, M. Kohler, F. Gramazio, Y. Weinand
in FABRICATE 2017
Integral joints provide a rapid, simple and mechanically strong connection between parts. Our investigation focuses on the assembly of cross-laminated wood veneer plates, where previous studies have shown that the strength of through-tenons is equivalent or superior to state-of-the-art fasteners such as screws or nails. This mechanical behaviour is highly dependent on a precise fit of the joints, where no gaps are left between the parts. However, the manual assembly of such tight-fitting joints can be complicated. Thanks to its rectangular cross-section, a single through-tenon joint is a sufficient assembly guide for an entire plate, but multiple through-tenons are required to establish a mechanically strong connection.
This results in a kinematically over-constrained assembly motion (Mantripragada et al., 1996). Additionally, due to fabrication- or material-related tolerances, the joints can be too tight-fitting and manual assembly motions deviate from the precise insertion path. So-called ‘wedging’ occurs during the assembly of tight-fitting joints, especially with larger parts at a building scale. This requires high forces to be overcome. Rather than leaving gaps between the parts, which presents one solution for the manual assembly of such systems, we investigate the assembly using an industrial robot. The robot allows for a more precise assembly motion and the application of higher forces in the direction of assembly. The aim of this research is to use these benefits along with the compressibility of wood for the assembly of oversized tenons. While in regular through-tenon joints the width of the tenon is equal to the width of the slot, the oversized tenons in this paper are slightly wider than their slot parts. This assembly will require a certain insertion force, squeezing the tenons into the holes, but the resulting connection will be tight-fitting without any gaps.
C. Robeller, Y. Weinand
in TEC21 Schweizerische Bauzeitung
Der neue Holzbau für einen Theatersaal in Vidy nimmt derzeit Gestalt an. Er liegt neben dem Theater, das Max Bill als Provisorium für die Expo 64, die Landesausstellung von 1964, entwarf (Situationsplan rechte Seite oben). Als Ersatz für den provisorischen Zeltbau wünschte die Bauherrschaft eine repräsentative, gedämmte und akustisch vorteilhaftere Spielstätte. Sie sollte ausserdem zu dem bestehenden Kubus von Max Bill passen, sich aber in Form und Material davon unterscheiden. Das durch das Institut du bois (IBOIS) sowie den Architekten des Atelier Cube erarbeitete Projekt, ein rasch zu erstellendes Faltwerk aus Holz als innovative architektonische Struktur, umweltfreundlich und zerlegbar, stiess auf Interesse.
Der neue Theatersaal verbindet Konstruktion und Formgebung zu einem selbstverständlich wirkenden Faltwerk. Die Verbindungstechnik geht auf eine der ältesten Methoden im Holzbau zurück, nämlich auf Holz-Holz-Verbindungen (Schwalbenschwanzverbindungen). Diese nutzt die Form von Bauteilen, um Kräfte zwischen ihnen zu übertragen. Das IBOIS der EPF Lausanne hat solche traditionelle Holzplattenverbindungen erforscht und in den baulichen Massstab übertragen. Die so entstandene neuartige Methode ermöglicht es, den Neubau beim Théâtre de Vidy als gefaltetes Plattentragwerk unter minimem Einsatz von Metallverbindern und Leim zu erstellen. Diese Befestigungstechnik ist selbst ein Beispiel von komplexeren, zweifach gekrümmten, gefalteten Flächentragwerken, die aus einer grossen Anzahl unterschiedlich geformter Bauteile bestehen.
C. Robeller, M. Konakovic, M. Dedijer, M. Pauly, Y. Weinand
in Advances in Architectural Geometry 2016
This paper presents a new lightweight construction system for doubly-curved shells, built from two interconnected layers of structural wood veneer plates. The system uses integral through-tenon joints for a fast, precise, and simple assembly, allowing for the construction of a series of differently shaped shells without a costly mould or support structure. Instead, inclined joints cut with a 5-axis CNC milling machine embed the correct location and angle between plates into the shape of the parts. This constrains the relative motions between joined parts to one assembly path. To take advantage of the benefits of such connectors, the constrained assembly paths must be considered in the fundamental design of the system, allowing for the insertion of each plate. This imposes additional constraints in the segmentation process of doubly-curved shells. In order to meet the requirements and resolve the multi-constraint system, we use a global, nonlinear optimization approach. Developed as a close collaboration between architects, computer scientists and structural engineers, the paper includes an experimental analysis of the influence of parametric modifications in the shape of connectors on their load-bearing performance.
While previous projects used dovetail joints for the connection of timber plates, the through-tenon joints provide an additional high resistance to bending forces. Like the dovetail joints, the through-tenons are also prismatic joints and reduce the mobility of parts to a single motion path. The use of prismatic joints, fabricated with a 5-axis CNC enabled cutting method, allows us to integrate the assembly instructions into the shape of the plates. Therefore, our construction system does not require a mould, which is crucial for the case study project with its 23 individually shaped shells. The tiling with trapezoidal shaped hexahedron segments was chosen to optimize the assembly of the structure, the mechanical strength of the joints and the transfer of forces within the structure.
A rotation of the tabs allows for the piece-by-piece assembly of small plates, connecting multiple edges simultaneously. We have analyzed the influence of this rotation on the shear strength of the joints and optimized the shape of our plates based on the results. The alternation of the joint rotation in every second row avoids long range escape paths, supporting our strategy of blocking parts with one another, using their form to reduce or replace the need for additional fasteners. At the same time, the alternating trapezoidal shape of the segments results in an alternating rotation of all edges across the direction of span on all shells. The length of these edges is increased and continuous bending axes are avoided. The research underlines the need for close interdisciplinary collaboration of architects, computer scientists, and engineers in the development of new types of sustainable lightweight structures, which are equally optimized for fast and precise assembly and for structural efficiency.
C. Robeller and Y. Weinand
in Robotic Fabrication in Architecture 2016, p. 166-177, Springer Verlag, 2016
Integral attachment, the joining of parts through their form rather than additional connectors or adhesives, is a common technique in many industry sectors. Following a renaissance of integral joints for timber frame structures, recent research investigates techniques for the attachment of timber plate structures. This paper introduces double through tenon joints, which allow for the rapid, precise and fully integral assembly of doubly-curved folded surface structures with two interconnected layers of cross-laminated engineered wood panels. The shape of the plates and the assembly sequence allow for an attachment without additional connectors or adhesives. The fabrication and assembly constraint based design is achieved through algorithms, which automatically generate the geometry of the parts and the G-Code for the fabrication. We present the fabrication and assembly of prototypes fabricated with 3D CNC milling and laser cutting systems, comparing and discussing the advantages and disadvantages of the individual techniques.
Through tenon joints for LVL panels combine the shear strength of finger joints with a high resistance to bending moments and out-of-plane traction. The prototypes presented in this paper demonstrate the additional possibility of using Double Through Tenon Joints for the integral attachment and spacing of double-layered timber plate structures. The plate configuration based on the Miura-Ori pattern allows for the design of fabrication- and assembly- aware doubly-curved folded surface structures. While the Yoshimura pattern is constrained to target surfaces with a high curvature and results in large plate sizes, the Miura-Ori pattern can also be applied to surfaces with a low curvature. However, the vertical elevation of the vertices in the Miura-Ori also results in certain structural disadvantages (Stitic et al., 2015). Further research is necessary to determine if the structurally advantageous shape of the Yoshimura pattern outweighs the disadvantages in its fabrication, joining and assembly.
Advantages of the joint configuration and assembly sequence described in section 4 of the paper, including the direct connection of each plate to 8 adjacent plates, as well as the mutual blocking of the plates which only allows for a piecewise disassembly in the reverse order of assembly. Therefore, a traction resistance of the joints is not required and additional connectors such as screws, metal plates or adhesives are not necessary. The production of prototypes with 3D milling as well as 2D and 3D laser cutting systems has shown advantages and disadvantages of the individual solutions. The highest quality cuts on LVL plates can be achieved with saw blades, due to the large diameter and the large number of blades. However the production of the concave polygonal contours and slots of the through tenon joints is not possible with such tools. Instead, we have used milling bits with a radius of 6 mm, which allowed for the production of precise parts. The tight fit and precision of the joints was confirmed by a load-test of the arch prototype. An alternative solution was presented for the fabrication of small-scale prototypes using a geometric adaptation of the joints for 2D laser systems. The method allows for the rapid production of precise models, however the plates are only in contact along lines, not surfaces. Further research is required analyzing the influence of this method on load-bearing joints. Finally, the advantages of the 3D milling and the 2D laser cutting were combined using a 3D laser system for the production of through tenon joints on structural grade LVL panels.
C. Robeller, Y. Weinand
in International Journal of Space Structures
Automatic joinery has become a common technique for the jointing of beams in timber framing and roofing. It has revived traditional, integrated joints such as mortise and tenon connections. Similarly, but only recently, the automatic fabri- cation of traditional cabinetmaking joints has been introduced for the assembly of timber panel shell structures. First prototypes have used such integrated joints for the alignment and assembly of components, while additional adhesive bonding was used for the load-bearing connection. However, glued joints cannot be assembled on site, which results in several design constraints. In this paper, we propose the use of dovetail joints without adhesive bonding, on the case study of a timber folded plate structure. Through their single-degree-of- freedom (1DOF) geometry, these joints block the relative movement of two parts in all but one direction. This presents the opportunity for an interlocking connection of plates, as well as a challenge for the assembly of folded plate shells, where multiple non-parallel edges per plate must be jointed simultaneously.
C. Robeller and Y. Weinand
in Proceedings of the World Conference of Timber Engineering WCTE 2016
Integral Mechanical Attachment (IMA) uses features in the form of components for their connection. In addition to the transfer of forces, locator features are used as integral assembly guides. Prismatic, single-degree-of-freedom (1DOF) joints only allow for a single assembly motion and therefore a simple, rapid and precise assembly. In modern timber construction, such CNC-fabricated 1DOF joints are commonly used in frame structures. Recent research is investigating the application of similar techniques for the joining of timber plate components, inspired by traditional handcrafted joints from cabinetmaking. The method presented in this paper builds upon previous research, allowing for new geometric variations such as non-orthogonal 1DOF plate joints and a simplified cutting process using a 5-axis simultaneous cutting technique. In addition to the use of milling tools, the method is compatible with 5-axis laser cutting and 5-axis waterjet cutting. Advantages and disadvantages of the different methods are being discussed.
P. Mayencourt, C. Loraux, C. Robeller, E. Brühwiler and Y. Weinand
in IABSE Conference - Structural Engineering, September 23-25 2015, Geneva, Switzerland
Folded plate structures or shells are statically efficient structures. However, their construction is limited by the complexity and cost of their formwork. We used Computer Numerical Control Milling Technology to design a wooden formwork for an Ultra-High Performance Fibre Reinforced cement-based Composite (UHPFRC) folded plate arch. This paper describes the design and assembly of a formwork made from cross-laminated veneer lumber panels (LVL) with integrated wood-wood connections and the testing of the resulting thin origami-like UHPFRC arch. Currently achieved for a lab scale, CNC wood milling technology combined with integrated panel joints could enable mass-customized formwork for complex structures. UHPFRC is probably the only existing material with required strength and sustainability properties for ultra-thin structures. However, special attention should be given to the casting direction and fibres orientation in sharp edges. Based on this consideration and the result of the first lab test, some geometric adjustments and construction details are proposed and discussed in this paper.
A. Stitic, C. Robeller and Y. Weinand
in IABSE Symposium Report, IABSE Conference Nara, 2015: Elegance in Structures, pp. 1-8(8)
This paper analyses the potential of different possible folded form topologies for generating timber folded surface structures. The main advantage of such structures lies primarily in the realm of ecology and sustainability. By offering an integral way of construction, which fulfils both a supporting as well as a covering function, very lightweight structures are achieved. Also, a greater degree of prefabrication is possible which leads to a reduced overall cost. As these structures consist of a large number of discrete, thin plane elements, proper edgewise connection details are needed in order to ensure an efficient load bearing system. For structures made of wood products this presents a great challenge using the state-of-the art joining techniques. For this reason, the use of timber folded plate structures in civil engineering applications has been very limited. However, recently new technical solutions have been proposed for efficient edgewise joining of thin timber panels. In this paper focus is put on integrated mechanical attachment technique which utilizes digital prefabrication to integrate connectors through panel geometry. Considering the material and the chosen connection detail fabrication as well as assembly related constraints, feasible folded forms for folded surface structures are explored. Their influence on structural performance is studied and different forms are compared by means of Finite Element Analysis. Furthermore, based on the obtained results, form improvements are proposed and observations made on a case study of a built prototype structure are presented.
S. Roche, C. Robeller, L. Humbert, Y. Weinand
in European Journal of Wood and Wood Products, p. 1-9, Springer Verlag, 2015
This paper focuses on multiple tab-and-slot joints (MTSJ) for load-carrying assembly of structural wood elements, which are inspired by traditional cabinetmaking joints and adapted for automatic fabrication and engineered wood panels such as laminated veneer lumber. First a numerical method is presented for the estimation of the connections’ semi-rigid properties based on box beam samples. In a simplified model, the mechanical behavior of the joint is represented by potential elastic slips at interfaces. They are handled by the model with the help of rigidity modulus, which is determined by matching simulated and experimental deflections. Finally, the influence of tab length and contact face angle on the semi-rigidity of the joint is discussed considering a dovetail geometry of the MTSJ. Glued and screwed samples serve as references in this study.
C. Robeller and Y. Weinand
EPFL Doctoral Thesis No. 6564
Timber folded plate Structures combine the advantages of timber as a construction material, such as its carbon-dioxide storage, low energy production and favorable weight-to-strength ratio, with the structural efficiency and elegance of folded surface structures. The construction of such surface-active structure systems with timber is a relatively new development, driven by an increasing awareness for sustainable building constructions, and enabled by new engineered wood products. However, these constructions require a large amount of edgewise joints between the thin timber plates, which are difficult to address with state-of-the-art connection techniques. Instead of using mass-produced mechanical fasteners for these connections, this thesis investigates the use of customized Integral Mechanical Attachment techniques, which use geometrical features of the parts to establish connections, rather than additional fasteners. Integral joints were common in traditional woodworking, but their manual crafting became infeasible during the industrialization.
Computer-controlled fabrication technology, which is already available in the timber prefabrication industry, allows for an efficient, automatic production of integral joints. The advantages of such joints have already been demonstrated in framing constructions, where timber beams are used as the primary structural components. The proliferation of automatic joinery machines has repatriated customizable single-degree-of-freedom (1DOF) joints, which allow for the fast and precise assembly of prefabricated components. The objective of this thesis is to transfer these advantages to the construction of timber folded plate structures. Inspiration is taken from traditional cabinetmaking joints from Europe and Asia, as well as other industry sectors, where mass-produced integral joints are commonly used.
Jury: Prof. M. Fröhlich (president), Prof. Y. Weinand (directeur), J. Hakkarainen, Prof. M. Kohler, Prof. M. Pauly (rapporteurs)
C. Robeller, B. Hahn, P. Mayencourt, Y. Weinand
in Bauingenieur vol. 89, p. 487-490, Springer VDI Verlag, 2014
Die weit verbreitete automatisierte Vorfertigung im Holzbau, sowie moderne CAD-Software mit Programmierschnittstellen ermöglichen und vereinfachen zunehmend die Herstellung von komplexen Bauteilgeometrien. Diese Entwicklung erfordert und ermöglicht gleichermaßen auch Anpassungen und Neuentwicklungen der Verbindungstechnik. Analog zu den Entwicklungen im Holzrahmenbau, demonstriert die hier vorgestellte prototypische Schalenkonstruktion aus gekrümmtem Brettsperrholz die Adaption einer klassischen Holz-Holz Zinkungsstechnik aus dem Tischlerhandwerk, die mithilfe eines Industrieroboters automatisch hergestellt werden kann. Diese ästhetisch anspruchsvolle, sichtbare Verbindung ermöglicht eine tragfähige geklebte Verbindung und vereinfacht die Fügung der Bauteile durch eine integrierte Positionierlehre.
C. Robeller and Y. Weinand
in ACADIA 2014 Design Agency, p. 189-198
This paper presents our reserach into the design and potential applications of CNC fabricated snap-fit joints for cross-laminated veneer lumber panels (LVL). These joints are new to the building construction sector, but commonly used in other domains such as the automotive or consumer electronics industry. We explain our application of existing knowledge about the design and dimensioning of such joints, as well as several adaptations that we have made in order to optimize the connectors for the jointing of structural wood panels. This was necessary due to the materials and fabrication processes in timber construction, which are different from those in the sectors of origin of the snap-fit joints. We propose applications, including two case studies with physical prototypes.
C. Robeller, S. S. Nabaei, Y. Weinand
in Robotic Fabrication in Architecture 2014, p. 67-81, Springer Verlag, 2014
The prototype presented in this chapter utilizes the technique of curved folding for the design of a thin-shell structure built from curved cross-laminated timber panels (CLT). The curved-folded geometry allows for a span of 13.5 m, at a shell thickness of only 77 mm. The construction requires curved line CLT joints, which are difficult to address with state-of-the-art jointing techniques for CLT. Inspired by traditional woodworking joinery, we have designed connections for the integrated attachment of curved CLT panels, utilizing digital geometry processing tools to combine the advantages of traditional joinery techniques with those of modern automation technology.